Skip to main content

Arabs don't progress because of their language?


Some of the linguists argue that Arabic world will never achieve scientific progress and progressive thinking due to the logical structure of their mother tongue.

Language has played a significant role in the rise and fall of civilizations. Since language is the portrait of human thoughts, it reflects the quality of thought generated in a society. The selection of language tools used to express thought reflects the priorities of a person or for that matter a nation. The way language is acquired can make a significant difference in the development of nation. The quality and quantity of language is a barometer of the intellectual health of the people.

Executive Director of the New Century Education, Rayed Afzal wrote once that that the growth of a society depends on two types of language skills. The BICS (Basic Interpersonal Communication Skills) concern with human feelings, social and religious arguments and entertainment. The CALP (Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency) is the language of science, the ability to present a problem, building a hypothesis, analyzing data and then presenting solutions. Since CALP mostly deals with data, facts and figures, it lacks the beauty of Shakespeare or the imagery of Mirza Ghalib.

Apparently, logical structure of Arabic language itself lacks of CALP which leads to lack of scientific knowledge and discoveries, creating a severe handicap for a society.

The Arabic alphabet has 28 letters, and is written from right to the left. It has a vast abundance of words, which enables the language to reach a level of precision. The words in Arabic are built on “roots”. For example, the combination of the letters `k-t-b` conveys the idea of the verb `to write`. By adding vowels, or affixes to the root, it is possible to derive many other words which have a closely associated meaning. We may derive words such as kutub (`books`), katib (`writer`), maktub (`letter`), maktab (`office`), miktaab (`typewriter`), maktaba (`library`) and iktitaab (`registration`). All these words have within them the consonants k, t and b (and always in that order), this represents the semantic root of the words and the idea of `writing`.

This means it is often much easier to figure out the meaning of a word in Arabic by looking at its basic root , rather than having to memorize words that do not have any obvious structural identification with the idea they represent.

Therefore, the logical structure of Arabic much differs from the Latin originated languages. The Latin based languages do foster precision in the use of words. When reading English or French or German closely and carefully, word by word, it focuses our mind on individual words and their usage. There may be a certain amount of stylistic imitation involved, but more important is the habit of reading closely and following important texts with accuracy.

While the West did away with BICS and successfully developed CALP of its people, leading to hundreds of scientific discoveries and inventions in the last three hundred years, the Arabic society full of color, warmth and beauty of speech, is still unable to move towards technical and scientific progress.

Comments

Hebrew has same structure as Arabic language.
And it does not stop Jewish people to evolve and stuff.
In fact Rambam was writing mainly in Arabic for some time, and he is one of the world recognized philosophers.
Plus Chomskiy proved that all languages a evolve in similar way since language skills are one of the basic functions of our brain and they are coded in DNA.
Plus Arabs were very evolved civilization, and they contributed greatly to the science and culture.
I believe Arabic lack of progress in modern time is a result of this Al Gazali guy work .He diverted Islam from classical Greek philosophy towards Islamic philosophy.He was clearly ahead of his time.Had he come today in the time of quantum physics ,his work could be ground breaking and stuff.But in 1000 it just alienated Arab culture from rest of the world, forbidding it to benefit from Renaissance fully.
Anonymous said…
This comment has been removed by the author.

Popular posts from this blog

Viva Brazil

The Christmas and New Year Eve were truly remarkable for me this year as I spent it in fantastic and mesmerising Brazil. My friend Caio was my guide there and as a native he could show me the best of Brazil: not only the touristic parts but also the whole beauty of small towns and suburbs, everyday life, traditions and culture. Considering that not many people speak English there I am so grateful to Caio for making this trip so amazing and stress free for me. Multifaceted and colourful Brazil is known for its nature, culture and rich history. In Brazil you can experience everything from architectural monuments of the colonial era, lively carnivals to  simply   a delicate aroma of coffee floating in the air. Among of all beautiful places Rio De Janeiro surely holds is pr imary position for me. Noisy, picturesque and ever bubbling Rio attracts by its excellent sandy beaches, luxurious hotels, unique sights and state-of-the-art architecture. To visit the city of all B...

The hero MUST die at the end…

R emember the famous Tolstoy’s quote “all happy families are the same”? The similar could also apply to the most of the movies with the happy endings. I don’t know whether it’s just me being weird, but in my opinion, Hollywood happy endings ruin some movies. You watch a film and all you remember afterwards is just the cliché at the end– main characters are happily in love, bad guys in prison, everything ideal…just as it’s meant to be. Isn’t it boring?! Many would disagree with me saying that there are enough negative things happening in our lives and films with happy endings make us forget about daily problems, deepen our believe in love and good triumphs over evil. So what is better – to be a spectator of a narrative history we love it closes where the bad are punished and that ultimately the conflict is resolved or... to watch a film which make you think about things or bring to you the most unexpected? What would stay in your memory and what the difference between a good fi...

Жизнь по- английски

Итак, моя первая статья на русском, впервые за последние 5 лет. Хммм, слова путаются в голове... Пытаюсь сформулировать мысль, но всё как-то машинально происходит на английском. Странно… вдруг понимаю, что не говорю в совершенстве ни на одном языке. Как говорят - "ни к селу ни к городу!" Итак, первая статейка… О чем она? Конечно же о самом важном, о личном опыте, о самой жизни - моей жизни в Британии. Наверное самой большой трудностью с которой я сталкнулась, приехав в Лондон, был "культурный шок", динамичность всего проиcшодящего вокруг, ну и, конечно же, какое-то странное чувство одиночества и ненужности. Но ко всему постепенно привыкаешь, приспосабливаешься. Такое доказательство теории Дарвина на собственной шкуре! Ну обо всём по порядку... Как я уже сказала, к такому культурному шоку я была не готова... И дело не только в бешеном ритме мегаполиса, куче достоприомечательностей мирового уровня, английского завтрака по утрам и " fish and chi...